Performance Bond Claims: What Happens When a Bond Is Called?
A practical guide to performance bond claims for UK contractors and beneficiaries, covering conditional and on-demand bonds, ABI wording, adjudication, insolvency, claim evidence, expiry, maximum liability, counter indemnities and what happens after a claim is submitted.
What Is a Performance Bond Claim?
A contractor being in difficulty does not necessarily mean that the beneficiary automatically receives the full bond amount.
The bond is a legal instrument with its own claim trigger, maximum liability, expiry provisions and procedural requirements.
The first question in almost every performance bond claim should therefore be: what does this particular bond actually require?
What Happens When a Performance Bond Is Called?
The process differs according to the type of bond, but a performance bond claim will normally involve several distinct stages.
A problem arises under the underlying contract
The beneficiary believes the contractor has failed to perform, is in breach, has become insolvent or that another event relevant to the bond has occurred.
The beneficiary reviews the bond
The claim trigger, evidence requirements, maximum liability, notice provisions and expiry need to be identified.
A claim or demand is submitted
The beneficiary provides the information and documentation required by the particular guarantee.
The guarantor considers its liability
Under a conditional bond this can require consideration of the contractor's underlying breach and the beneficiary's loss. Under an on-demand guarantee the immediate question may instead be whether the demand complies with the terms of the guarantee.
The claim is accepted, disputed or investigated further
Further evidence, contractual decisions, calculations or legal analysis may be required depending on the bond.
Payment may be made
If liability is established, the guarantor may pay the amount due, subject to the maximum liability and other terms of the bond.
Recourse may follow
If the guarantor incurs a recoverable loss, its rights under the associated counter indemnity may become relevant.
How Is a Conditional Performance Bond Claimed?
Conditional bonds are therefore sometimes referred to as default bonds or guarantees of secondary liability.
A typical claim may require consideration of:
Contractual Breach
Has the contractor actually breached an obligation covered by the guarantee?
Resulting Loss
What financial loss has the beneficiary suffered because of that breach?
Amount Due
Has the loss been established or determined in the manner required by the bond?
The existence of a disagreement, delay or contractor insolvency may be relevant, but the beneficiary still needs to satisfy the legal requirements contained in the actual guarantee.
Conditional vs On-Demand Performance Bonds →How Does a Claim Work Under an ABI Performance Bond?
The standard structure links the guarantor's obligation to a breach of the underlying contract and damages sustained by the beneficiary that have been established and ascertained in accordance with or by reference to the underlying contract.
That creates two important questions:
- Has the contractor incurred the relevant underlying liability?
- Has the amount claimed been established in an appropriate way?
Can an Adjudicator's Decision Trigger a Performance Bond Claim?
This is important because it demonstrates that a conditional performance bond does not necessarily require the beneficiary to obtain a final court judgment before it can establish a claim.
Construction adjudication can provide a binding interim determination of a contractual dispute. Where the underlying contract uses adjudication and the performance bond refers to amounts being established and ascertained by reference to that contract, an adjudication decision may therefore be highly significant.
The precise bond wording, underlying contract, scope of the adjudication and terms of the decision still need to be considered.
How Is an On-Demand Performance Bond Claimed?
The guarantor may not be entitled to delay payment while the contractor and beneficiary resolve the merits of the underlying construction dispute.
The guarantee may require:
- a written demand;
- specified wording or declarations;
- identification of the alleged default;
- supporting documents or certification;
- authorised signatures;
- delivery in a specified manner;
- presentation before expiry.
The circumstances in which payment under an on-demand guarantee can be restrained are limited and highly fact-sensitive. Anyone facing an actual or threatened demand should obtain urgent specialist legal advice.
Conditional vs On-Demand Guide →What Evidence Is Needed for a Performance Bond Claim?
There is no universal evidence checklist because the required proof depends on the guarantee and the underlying contract.
The Performance Bond
The claimant needs the executed bond and any amendments, schedules or extensions.
The Underlying Contract
A conditional claim may require the relevant contract, amendments, specifications and contractual provisions.
Evidence of Breach
Correspondence, notices, termination documents, contractual decisions and other evidence may be relevant.
Loss Calculation
The beneficiary may need to demonstrate how the amount claimed has been calculated.
Adjudication or Decisions
An adjudicator's decision, judgment, award or other contractual determination may be important.
Formal Demand
For demand guarantees, strict compliance with the required form of demand can be crucial.
Can a Performance Bond Be Claimed After It Expires?
Some bonds expire on a fixed calendar date. Others use a contractual event or another release mechanism.
The beneficiary should therefore check:
- the stated expiry date;
- whether extensions have been executed;
- how a claim must be delivered;
- where it must be sent;
- whether receipt rather than dispatch is required;
- whether the wording preserves existing claims after expiry.
Does Contractor Insolvency Automatically Trigger a Performance Bond?
A performance bond is not automatically the same as insolvency insurance. The beneficiary still needs to identify the contractual consequences of the insolvency and establish whatever liability the bond requires.
For example, the beneficiary may need to determine:
What Has Happened Under the Contract?
- Has an insolvency event occurred?
- Has the contract been terminated?
- Has the contractor committed a relevant breach?
- What contractual rights have arisen?
What Loss Has Resulted?
- Cost of completing outstanding works
- Amounts otherwise due to the contractor
- Defects or rectification costs
- Other sums recoverable under the contract
Can a Performance Bond Claim Be Rejected?
Yes. A guarantor is not necessarily required to pay simply because a beneficiary has submitted a claim.
Potential issues can include:
No Qualifying Breach
A conditional bond may not respond if the contractor has no relevant underlying liability.
Loss Not Established
The beneficiary may not yet have established the damages required by the wording.
Incorrect Demand
A demand may fail to comply with the formal requirements stated in the guarantee.
Expired Bond
The claim may have been made after the guarantee ceased to be available.
Wrong Claim Amount
The amount demanded may exceed the contractual loss or maximum liability.
Wrong Claimant
Questions can arise regarding the beneficiary, assignment or whether the party demanding payment is entitled to enforce the guarantee.
How Much Can Be Claimed Under a Performance Bond?
The bond amount normally represents the guarantor's maximum stated liability, but it does not necessarily mean that the beneficiary is automatically entitled to claim that entire amount.
Contract value: £5,000,000
Performance bond: 10%
Maximum bond liability: £500,000
If the beneficiary has an established qualifying loss of £180,000, a conditional bond does not ordinarily become a £500,000 windfall. The actual entitlement depends on the bond and contractual loss.
Likewise, if qualifying damages exceed the bond amount, the guarantor's liability under the bond will normally remain subject to its stated maximum.
Can More Than One Claim Be Made Under a Performance Bond?
That depends on the particular wording.
Some guarantees may allow more than one claim provided the aggregate liability does not exceed the bond limit. Others may operate differently or be discharged following payment.
What Should a Contractor Do If a Performance Bond Claim Is Threatened?
The contractor should treat a threatened bond claim seriously and act quickly, particularly where the bond is on-demand or the beneficiary alleges an immediate entitlement to payment.
Review the Bond Immediately
- Conditional or on-demand?
- What is the claim trigger?
- What evidence is required?
- When does the bond expire?
- What is the maximum liability?
Review the Underlying Contract
- Is there actually a breach?
- Has the contractual procedure been followed?
- Are notices valid?
- Is adjudication already underway?
- Are there counterclaims or sums due to the contractor?
Contact the Bond Provider
- Do not ignore the threatened claim
- Provide relevant correspondence
- Explain the contractual position
- Preserve supporting documentation
Consider Legal Advice Quickly
- Particularly for on-demand guarantees
- Where an injunction may be contemplated
- Where adjudication is relevant
- Where insolvency is involved
- Where substantial sums are at risk
What Should a Beneficiary Check Before Calling a Performance Bond?
A beneficiary should avoid treating the bond as an unrestricted pot of money. The validity of the claim depends on compliance with the guarantee.
Entitlement
Identify precisely which contractual breach or demand provision is being relied upon.
Evidence
Confirm that the required loss, certificate, adjudication decision or other evidence exists.
Procedure
Comply carefully with demand format, signatures, delivery and expiry requirements.
Submitting an unsupported or incorrectly documented claim can create unnecessary delay and potentially lead to a dispute over whether the bond responds at all.
What Happens If the Bond Provider Pays the Claim?
Payment by the guarantor may not be the end of the matter for the contractor.
Performance bonds are commonly supported by a counter indemnity under which the contractor, parent company, directors or other indemnifying parties may have agreed to reimburse the provider for qualifying losses and costs.
The position can be especially important under an on-demand guarantee because the guarantor may make payment before the contractor's underlying dispute with the beneficiary has been finally resolved.
Performance Bond Indemnity Guide →How Can Contractors Reduce Performance Bond Claim Risk?
The best time to consider claim risk is before the bond is issued, not after a dispute develops.
Review the Wording
Avoid accepting unnecessarily onerous demand or amendment clauses without understanding their consequences.
Understand the Contract
Know the events, notices and procedures that could lead to termination or other liability.
Manage Problems Early
Project delays, disputes and financial issues generally become harder to resolve the longer they are left.
Know the Indemnity
Understand the financial consequences if the bond provider ultimately makes a payment.
More Performance Bond Guidance
Performance Bonds
Complete guide to UK performance bonds, how they work and how to obtain terms.
Performance Bond Guide →Conditional vs On-Demand
Understand the fundamental difference between the two principal claim structures.
Compare Bond Types →Performance Bond Wordings
Understand ABI wording, bespoke amendments and the clauses affecting liability.
Wording Guide →Performance Bond Indemnity
Understand the contractor's potential recourse exposure following a bond payment.
Indemnity Guide →JCT Performance Bonds
Performance bond requirements and wording issues under JCT contracts.
JCT Guide →Performance Bond Claims FAQs
What happens when a performance bond is called?
The guarantor considers whether the beneficiary has satisfied the claim requirements contained in the bond. With a conditional bond this normally involves underlying contractor liability and loss. With an on-demand guarantee the immediate focus may be whether a compliant demand has been presented.
Does the beneficiary automatically receive the full bond amount?
No. Under a conditional performance bond, the amount recoverable normally depends on the qualifying loss established, subject to the maximum liability. The bond amount is a cap rather than automatically the amount payable.
Can a contractor dispute a performance bond claim?
Potentially. The available arguments depend heavily on whether the guarantee is conditional or on-demand and on the wording and facts of the claim. A dispute under the underlying contract does not necessarily prevent payment under a genuine on-demand guarantee.
Does insolvency automatically trigger a performance bond?
Not necessarily. Insolvency may trigger rights under the underlying contract, but the beneficiary still needs to satisfy the particular requirements of the performance bond.
Can an adjudicator's decision support an ABI performance bond claim?
Potentially yes. An adjudicator's decision can in appropriate circumstances establish and ascertain the amount due for the purposes of an ABI-type conditional bond, depending on the underlying contract and bond wording.
Does adjudication turn an ABI bond into an on-demand bond?
No. The liability is still being established through a contractual decision-making mechanism. That is different from payment becoming due merely because a demand has been presented.
Can a performance bond claim be made after expiry?
It depends on the exact wording, but where the guarantee requires a valid claim or demand before a stated expiry date, failing to do so can prevent a claim. Any continuing rights after expiry depend on the document.
Can a surety refuse to pay a performance bond claim?
Potentially. A claim may fail because the conditions for liability have not been satisfied, the required loss has not been established, the demand does not comply with the wording, the bond has expired or another defence is available.
Can several claims be made against the same performance bond?
Possibly, depending on the wording. The guarantee may permit multiple claims subject to an aggregate liability cap, or it may operate differently. The particular bond must be checked.
Who ultimately pays if a surety pays a valid bond claim?
The guarantor makes the payment to the beneficiary, but it may then have rights of recovery against the contractor or other indemnifying parties under the relevant counter indemnity.
Can an employer call an on-demand bond even when the contractor says no money is owed?
Potentially yes. A genuine on-demand bond is designed to operate separately from the final resolution of the underlying contractual dispute, provided the beneficiary submits a demand satisfying the guarantee's requirements.
What should I do if a performance bond claim is threatened?
Review the complete bond and underlying contract immediately, preserve the relevant project documents, notify the bond provider and consider obtaining specialist legal advice, particularly where an on-demand guarantee or a significant claim is involved.
Need Performance Bond Terms?
If you require a performance bond for a current or upcoming contract, send us the bond value, contract details, required date and proposed wording.
- Conditional performance bonds
- ABI and bespoke wording
- NEC3, NEC4 and JCT projects
- UK construction and commercial contracts
- Urgent requirements considered