Performance Bond Indemnity: A Guide for UK Contractors
Understand performance bond indemnities and deeds of counter indemnity, why bond providers require them, who may be asked to sign, the difference between company and personal indemnity, and what can happen if a bond claim results in a payment.
What Is a Performance Bond Indemnity?
It is commonly referred to as a counter indemnity, deed of counter indemnity, surety indemnity or agreement of indemnity.
The performance bond protects the beneficiary. The indemnity protects the bond provider.
This distinction is important because contractors sometimes assume that paying a bond premium means the provider is simply accepting the contractor's performance risk in the same way that an insurer might accept an insured risk. That is not normally how surety operates.
Performance bonds are generally written on a recourse basis. The provider supports the contractor's obligation to the beneficiary, but may retain contractual rights to recover qualifying losses from the indemnifying parties.
Why Is an Indemnity Required for a Performance Bond?
The indemnity helps align the financial risk between the contractor and the bond provider.
When a guarantor issues a performance bond, it places its own financial standing behind the contractor's contractual obligation. If a valid bond claim results in the guarantor making a payment, the indemnity can provide a contractual route for recovery from the indemnifying parties.
Recourse
The indemnity can allow the provider to seek reimbursement for qualifying losses arising from the bond.
Risk Alignment
The contractor continues to carry the underlying commercial risk rather than transferring it entirely to the guarantor.
Underwriting Support
The financial strength of the proposed indemnitors can form part of the provider's assessment of the application.
Performance Bond vs Counter Indemnity
| Issue | Performance Bond | Counter Indemnity |
|---|---|---|
| Who receives the protection? | The beneficiary of the underlying contract. | The bond provider or guarantor. |
| Who normally gives the obligation? | The guarantor or bond provider. | The contractor and/or other agreed indemnifying parties. |
| Main purpose | Provides financial security for the contractor's performance obligations. | Provides recourse to the guarantor for amounts recoverable under the indemnity. |
| When does it matter most? | When the beneficiary seeks to make a claim. | When the guarantor incurs a loss, pays a claim or incurs other recoverable costs. |
| Who should review it? | The contractor, beneficiary and their professional advisers as appropriate. | The proposed indemnitors and their advisers, particularly where personal or group liability is involved. |
What Types of Performance Bond Indemnity Can Be Required?
There is no single indemnity structure that applies to every performance bond. Requirements depend on the applicant, corporate structure, bond amount, financial strength and provider.
Company Indemnity
The applicant company agrees to indemnify the bond provider in accordance with the agreed documentation.
Parent or Group Indemnity
A parent company or other group company may be asked to support the applicant, particularly where financial strength sits elsewhere within the group.
Personal Indemnity
Directors, shareholders or other individuals may in some circumstances be asked to provide personal support.
Additional Security
In higher-risk cases the provider may consider cash, a charge, other collateral or another form of security in addition to an indemnity.
Do Performance Bonds Require a Personal Indemnity?
Whether personal support is requested can depend on factors such as the applicant's size, net assets, profitability, ownership structure, financial history, bond amount and overall underwriting risk.
For a well-capitalised established company, a provider may be comfortable with corporate indemnity alone. For a smaller, weaker or closely held company, additional support may be requested.
What Happens to the Indemnity If a Performance Bond Is Called?
A call on the bond and a claim under the indemnity are separate stages. What happens depends on the wording of both documents and the circumstances of the claim.
The beneficiary makes a bond claim
The guarantor considers the claim according to the type and wording of the performance bond.
The guarantor assesses its obligation
Under a conditional bond this may involve consideration of contractor default and loss. A demand-style guarantee can operate differently.
A payment or other loss may arise
If the provider becomes liable and makes a payment, or incurs other costs recoverable under the indemnity, its rights under the counter indemnity may become relevant.
The provider may seek reimbursement
The provider can seek recovery from the indemnifying parties to the extent permitted by the actual indemnity agreement.
For more detail on what happens when a beneficiary seeks payment, see our dedicated claims guide.
Performance Bond Claims →Why Does the Bond Wording Matter to the Indemnity?
Because the easier it is for a beneficiary to trigger payment under the bond, the sooner the contractor may face potential recourse under the associated indemnity.
Conditional Performance Bond
A conventional conditional bond normally requires the beneficiary to satisfy conditions connected with contractor breach and loss before the guarantor becomes liable.
That underlying claim process can affect whether and when the guarantor incurs a recoverable loss.
On-Demand Performance Bond
A genuinely on-demand guarantee may require payment following a compliant demand before the underlying contractual dispute has been finally resolved.
This can increase the contractor's practical recourse exposure because a payment by the guarantor may arise considerably earlier.
What Can a Performance Bond Indemnity Cover?
The answer depends entirely on the document being signed, but indemnity agreements can be drafted to cover more than the face value of a bond claim.
Bond Payments
Amounts paid by the guarantor in satisfaction or settlement of qualifying claims can fall within the indemnity.
Professional & Legal Costs
Some indemnities provide for recovery of specified costs incurred investigating, defending, settling or dealing with bond claims.
Enforcement Costs
The document may also address costs incurred by the guarantor in enforcing its rights against an indemnitor.
What Does Joint and Several Indemnity Mean?
Where more than one party provides an indemnity, the document may state that their obligations are joint and several.
This can be particularly important where several group companies or individuals are asked to sign the same indemnity.
Anyone entering a joint and several obligation should understand that their potential liability may not simply correspond to their ownership percentage or perceived share of responsibility.
Is an Indemnity the Same as Collateral?
For many acceptable performance bond risks, an indemnity may be the principal security requirement. In other circumstances, however, underwriting may require additional security.
Cash Security
Funds may be deposited or otherwise controlled to support a bond exposure.
Charges or Security
A provider may in some circumstances seek security over assets or accounts.
Group Support
A stronger parent or associated company may provide additional financial support.
The security structure is an underwriting decision and should be established before the contractor assumes that a particular bond facility will be available.
Does the Indemnity Affect Performance Bond Cost?
It can form part of the overall underwriting assessment, although the premium is not determined by indemnity alone.
Performance bond pricing may reflect the financial strength of the applicant, bond amount, duration, contract risk, wording, existing exposure and the quality of the indemnity or other security available.
Stronger Security
Strong corporate or group support may improve the provider's overall view of the risk.
Weaker Balance Sheet
Additional indemnity or security may sometimes enable a provider to consider a requirement that would otherwise be difficult.
Onerous Bond Wording
Strong indemnity does not automatically make highly onerous bond wording acceptable. Both aspects are considered.
Does the Indemnity End When the Performance Bond Expires?
Expiry of the bond can prevent new claims from arising under the guarantee subject to its wording, but the indemnity may continue to apply to losses, claims, costs or liabilities arising from bonds issued while the agreement was in force.
A general indemnity agreement may also support more than one existing or future bond rather than being limited to a single project.
What Should a Contractor Check in a Counter Indemnity?
The indemnity deserves the same attention as the bond itself, particularly where directors, shareholders or group companies are being asked to assume liability.
Who Is Giving the Indemnity?
- Applicant company
- Parent company
- Other group companies
- Directors or shareholders personally
- Whether liability is joint and several
What Can Be Recovered?
- Amounts paid under the bond
- Claim investigation costs
- Legal and professional expenses
- Interest where applicable
- Enforcement costs
What Powers Does the Provider Have?
- Ability to settle a claim
- Ability to demand reimbursement
- Rights to security or collateral
- Rights following financial deterioration
- Information and reporting requirements
How Long Does It Continue?
- Single bond or general facility
- Existing and future bonds
- Bond extensions
- Termination provisions
- Continuing liability after termination
Why Might an Underwriter Ask for Stronger Indemnity?
A request for stronger security does not necessarily mean that a bond cannot be arranged. It may simply reflect the level or structure of the exposure being considered.
Large Bond
The requested guarantee may be significant relative to the applicant's balance sheet.
Weak Net Assets
The applicant may have insufficient tangible financial strength on a standalone basis.
Group Structure
Assets or profits may sit in another company rather than the contracting entity.
Higher-Risk Wording
The proposed guarantee may expose the provider to a more immediate or uncertain claim risk.
Rather than assuming that an additional indemnity request means the case has failed, it can be worth considering whether a different provider, wording, corporate structure or security arrangement produces a more suitable solution.
Continue Your Research
Performance Bonds
Start with our complete guide to how UK performance bonds work.
Performance Bond Guide →Conditional vs On-Demand
Understand how the payment trigger can affect both bond and indemnity exposure.
Compare Bond Types →Performance Bond Claims
See what happens when a beneficiary seeks payment under the guarantee.
Claims Guide →Performance Bond Requirements
See the company, financial and contract information normally required.
Requirements Guide →Performance Bond Wordings
Learn why the wording of the beneficiary's guarantee can affect the contractor's risk.
Wording Guide →Performance Bond Indemnity FAQs
What is a deed of counter indemnity?
It is a legal agreement under which the indemnifying party agrees to reimburse the bond provider for losses or other amounts falling within the terms of the indemnity in connection with the bond.
Is a counter indemnity always required for a performance bond?
Some form of indemnity or recourse arrangement is commonly required in surety bonding, but the precise document and security structure vary between providers and applicants.
Does a director always have to personally guarantee a performance bond?
No. Personal indemnity is not automatically required in every case. Requirements depend on the applicant, financial strength, ownership structure, bond value and provider.
Can a performance bond expose my personal assets?
Potentially, if you personally sign an indemnity or provide personal security. The existence of a limited company does not automatically protect an individual from obligations they separately enter into in their own name.
Is the indemnity limited to the performance bond amount?
Not necessarily. While the bond itself normally contains a maximum liability, the indemnity may also address items such as costs, expenses, interest or enforcement costs. The actual document determines the scope.
What happens if the surety pays a performance bond claim?
The surety may then seek reimbursement from the indemnifying parties to the extent permitted by the counter indemnity. The exact rights depend on the documentation and circumstances.
Does an on-demand bond increase my indemnity risk?
It can increase practical exposure because an on-demand guarantee may require the guarantor to pay following a compliant demand before the underlying contract dispute has been finally resolved.
Can a parent company provide the indemnity instead of a director?
Potentially. Group or parent-company support can be considered where appropriate, but whether it is sufficient is an underwriting decision for the relevant provider.
Can I negotiate the indemnity?
Potentially, depending on the provider and circumstances. If a proposed indemnity creates material concerns, these should ideally be raised before the bond is issued rather than after the document has been signed.
Does the counter indemnity end when the project finishes?
Not necessarily. The bond and indemnity are separate agreements. The indemnity may continue in relation to liabilities associated with bonds issued while it was in force, and a general indemnity may cover more than one bond.
Need a Performance Bond?
Tell us about the contract, bond value and required date and we can review the requirement.
- UK construction and commercial contracts
- NEC3, NEC4 and JCT requirements
- Conditional and bespoke bond wordings
- Different indemnity structures considered
- Urgent requirements considered